• Здраво и добредојдовте на форумот на IT.mk.

    Доколку сеуште не сте дел од најголемата заедница на ИТ професионалци и ентузијасти во Македонија, можете бесплатно да се - процесот нема да ви одземе повеќе од 2-3 минути, а за полесна регистрација овозможивме и регистрирање со Facebook и Steam.

Internet Explorer посигурен од Mozilla Firefox

Статус
Затворена за нови мислења.
  • Ја почнал/а темата
  • #1

LiquidWorm

Администратор
26 март 2007
2,667
183
www.zeroscience.mk
Mozilla rubbishes IE Firefox security study

Mozilla developers have hit back at a Microsoft study that suggests Internet Explorer is more secure than Firefox.

The study, Internet Explorer and Firefox Vulnerability Analysis, is based on a comparison between the number and severity of security updates issued for IE and Firefox since the release of Firefox in November 2004.

In the three years since then, Microsoft has fixed 87 vulnerabilities in various flavours of IE while Mozilla has patched 199 vulnerabilities in Firefox products.

The report, compiled by Jeff Jones, a security strategy director in Microsoft's Trustworthy Computing group, also found IE scored fewer vulnerabilities than Firefox across all categories of severity.

Mozilla said Microsoft's comparison is, at best, meaningless.

"Just because dentists fix more teeth in America doesn't mean our teeth are worse than in Africa," Mike Shaver, chief evangelist for Mozilla told eWEEK. Shaver took particular exception at Microsoft's decision to equate a large number of bug fixes with insecure software.

"It's something you'd expect from maybe an undergrad," he said. "It's very disappointing to see somebody in a senior security position come out and say that because an organisation is more transparent about their bugs and fixing them, they're somehow less secure."

Shaver added that even taken on its own merits the comparison between IE and Firefox is potentially misleading because Redmond often bundles multiple fixes in a single update, a phenomenon repeated to an even greater extent with the release of service packs.

Mozilla is putting an effort into encouraging users to update to the latest version of its software more quickly alongside greater emphasis on rapidly responding to security problems. Microsoft's efforts to suggest this is a bad thing are out of tune with the rest of the industry, Shaver argues.

"Shouldn't they be trying to fix more bugs, rather than writing reports that would 'punish' them for actively improving the security of their users rather than hoping that defects aren't found by someone who they can't keep quiet?"

"Microsoft should be embarrassed to be associated with this sort of ridiculous 'analysis'. We don't pretend that hiding the rate of fixes improves our users' security in any way, and we never will. We're transparent and aggressive in dealing with security issues, and 130 million Firefox users are safer for it every day," Shaver writes in a blog posting here.

Microsoft's Jones is no stranger to controversy. His previous study - a comparison between the number of security vulnerabilities in Windows Vista, Mac OS X, and Ubuntu Linux in the first six months of availability of the respective OSes - united Mac and Linux fans in opposition to Redmond's contention that Vista was more secure than its rivals.
Извор: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/12/03/moz_ie_security_comparison/

:spienje:
 

vik

Intern
14 април 2007
1,936
31
Ова јас мислам дека нема врска. Како со вика чоеков:

Just because dentists fix more teeth in America doesn't mean our teeth are worse than in Africa
Поголемиот број закрпи не значи дека не чини продуктот, значи дека грешки се најдени и поправени.

И ако гледаме од друга стана помалку закрпи за IE значи дека поглем број пропусти не се најдени и некои нема да се најдаат се додека не се направи некоја штета.

Така да Firefox Ruelz!
 

vojkan

Intern
19 јуни 2007
404
4
Поголемиот број закрпи не значи дека не чини продуктот, значи дека грешки се најдени и поправени.
Poshto site znaeme deka windows-ot e shvajcarsko sirenje, pogornoto mozhe da se kazhe i za windows-ot neli?

Od druga strana gledano, kako go komentirash sledniov tekst:
Mozilla Corp. will fix just 20% of the bugs now in Firefox 3.0 before the final version is released next year, the open-source developer's Web site revealed yesterday.
Kako kje se osekjash da ti kazhe naprimer VW, eve ti nov passat koj delumno samo 20% raboti, ama doagjaj redovno na servis i kje gi sredime ostanatite 80%.
Fala, no jas ne bi sakal da pravam online shopping i online banking so 20% produkt!

Ili kako go komentirash faktot deka 20 dena posle Firefox 2.0.0.9, izleguva 2.0.0.10, a samo 4 dena posle toa izleguva 2.0.0.11?
Dali 4 dena se dovolni za testiranje na novata zakrpa od 0.10 na 0.11 koga 20 dena ne bile dovolni za 0.9 na 0.10?
Sekoj normalen programer ili programerska kukja prvo vrshi testiranje na svojot produkt pred da go pushti vo eter, a firefox tuka potrfli!

I pokraj toa shto sum ljubitel na firefox, mislam deka firefox e daleku od toa shto beshe i pochna da gi gubi simpatiite (barem kaj mene). Ne sakam slepo da veruvam vo neshto, koga obratnoto vekje se dokazhuva!
 
Статус
Затворена за нови мислења.

Нови мислења

Последни Теми

Статистика

Теми
43,580
Мислења
823,869
Членови
28,079
Најнов член
ivannalex
На врв Дно